Hm, interesting. I found this article:
http://owl-workshop.man.ac.uk/acceptedLong/submission_12.pdf (Drummond et al. 2006) in a StackOverflow thread about lists in OWL. It looks like it just re-implements that classic Lisp-style linked list structure used by RDF:List, but in OWL.
So that's one option, but I don't really need to do much, if any, reasoning over the list, so I could just create a placeholder, dummy class that is included in the domain of a "containsListElement" object property.
Unless there's some existing list ontologies I could just import. I will research those options, but if anyone has any recommendations on one to use, that would be much appreciated.
Thanks!